February 2002
The story is narrated by Reuben, who is 11 at the time it takes place.
But the best part of this book isn't its story, though it too is
wonderful. No, the best part is the writing. I have a notebook in which
I copy passages from books that I have loved -- they have touched me or
impressed me or made me smile. But ten pages into this one, I realized
the only solution would be to just rubberband the entire novel to my
notebook -- I was copying at least every other paragraph down! Single
sentences made me gasp. And when I got to the last page, I was choking
back tears not just because the ending is so movingly happy and sad, but
because I knew the book was over and I would never ever be able to read it
again for the first time. When was the last time a book made you feel
like that? When was the last time the way an author strung words together
made your chest ache? If you, like me, LIVE for books like that, you need
to read this book ASAP. And, when you're finished, fire off a letter just
like mine to the book's editor, begging him to please make Enger publish
the complete Sunny Sundown poem posthaste. I'm just dying to hear what
really happened to Valdez. I can't recommend this book highly enough. If
you read only ONE of the books I recommend, make it this one!!
Just as they are giving up hope, though, they pick up another signal
emanating from the planet. It seems as though someone is trying to point
them in a specific direction out in space. Thinking it might be a
distress signal, and maybe thinking they don't have anything better to do
anyway, they follow the beacon, which leads them directly to an alien ship
adrift in space. Scans indicate it is uninhabited, but the ship sends a
crew to investigate. Though a few of them die almost immediately in freak
accidents, all in all, they find the ship too interesting to ignore. But
it definitely appears to be deserted. Um, until the explorers return the
next day to find it now has gravity. And then the day after to discover
the ship has breathable atmosphere. Something is clearly on the ship --
something that knows what they are and wants them there. Is it good or
evil, though? And, perhaps more importantly, what is its connection to
the horrors of the planet below?
The suspense almost gave me a heart attack, seriously. This is hands-down
the most exciting sci-fi thriller I've read since Orson Scott Card's
"Ender's Game." While I was a little disappointed in the ending, the rest
was so great I hardly cared. If you love a good space disaster novel,
this is the book for you. Recommended!!
The voyage gets off to a rocky start when Captain Patten loses his first
choice for First Mate and is forced by time constraints to hire a Mate
named Keeler he knows little about. Sure enough, Keeler turns out to be a
lousy seaman -- not only lazy and careless, but mutinous as well. Keeler
and Patten's relationship goes from tense to violent when Keeler
eventually attacks the Captain. He's quickly restrained and locked in the
brig, but not before landing a solid blow to the Captain's head.
Four days later, the Captain is felled by a mysterious fever (which may or
may not be related to the blow to the head). Now the ship is down both
First Mate and Captain -- just as it enters the treacherous waters around
the Cape. The Second Mate, Hare, is capable but timid and he quickly
takes a shaky command. The only problem is, he can't read or write -- and
therefore, he's never learned how to navigate. And without a navigator,
they're all doomed to be lost at sea.
Luckily, in her spare time on the ship, Mary has learned to use the
sextant. So, while nursing her husband as best she can, she also unites
with Hare to attempt to lead the ship and its crew on to its final
destination. And boy oh boy, is it ever a challenge.
I really enjoyed this novel a lot. The nautical stuff was fun (so THAT'S
how a sextant works!), but what I really loved was seeing Mary switch from
young, dutiful wife to Old Salt without missing a beat. It was a thrill
and inspiration to know it was a true story, as well. She's one amazing
lady! Additionally, the writing is truly wonderful. I could almost feel
the sea spray on my cheek during some of the passages. All in all, this
is a terrific novel. Highly, highly recommended!
Of
course, if all went as planned, we'd just close the book and turn on CBS.
Lord knows the cast of the latest Survivor installment was far more
interesting than the totally 2-D characters in this book. But when
everyone but the 13 players dies during the first broadcast and a voice
announces that the rules have changed, I got intrigued. Call me crazy.
The voice, "Control," says they've all been infected with a deadly virus
(which everybody kept comparing to Ebola even though it was NOTHING LIKE
EBOLA -- this got on my nerves after awhile, probably cuz I'm a
biochemistry snob). Anyway, without a vaccine injection every 24 hours,
the contestants will die just like the crew did. The game is to continue
as planned, but every day at noon, viewers will vote one person out -- and
that person will be denied that day's dose of the vaccine.
This intrigued me not because it was particularly clever or thrilling, but
because I assumed it was going to lead to something interesting. It was a
direction I thought was obvious -- would the American public really play
along? Really vote to KILL someone off each day? Despite witnessing
first-hand the torturous pain the virus inflicts when left unchecked? Yet
instead of an exploration of this, the plot follows a completely shallow
and straight path. The bad guys lose, the good guys win. And nothing is
made of the fact viewers did indeed vote to execute 8 or 9 people before
the game was stopped.
Clearly Brown didn't find that all that unusual. Even the parents of a
teenage boy who has become addicted to the 24 hour coverage end up helping
him vote to kill one of the contestants who has flipped out and turned
into a homicidal maniac. Brown sets the scene up like this: parents
confront boy who has missed FOUR DAYS OF SCHOOL (how COULD he let his
grades slip like that! He's a GOOD BOY!). Boy makes excuses. Parents
ground him and decide to take his computer. But as the Dad goes to grab
the monitor, they all notice that the crazy contestant is trying to KILL
the hero! And, as a family, they sit down and immediately vote so many
times to kill off the nutter that their fingers are sore! Well, thank god
these fine people were watching! Thank god they voted to kill that guy
before he could hurt anybody! Thank god nobody bothered to think, "Hey,
that guy might not have turned into a homicidal maniac had someone not
infected him with a deadly virus, forced him to watch others die from the
disease, and then told him he had less than 10 days to live himself.
Maybe we ought to cut him some slack?" Thank god everybody in the
world apparently had no problem with voting to kill complete strangers
for no good reason.
Anyway, not only did this book do its best to ignore any call for deep
thought, it's also chock full of stupid dialogue, characters so
stereotypical they don't even seem human, and just plain ol' carelessness.
For example, are we really supposed to believe that the designers of the
24/7 game didn't put any safeguards in place to keep people from voting
more than once? Hell, I could set up a system preventing that myself in
ten minutes! And, for pete's sake, why all the references to Ebola, which
has absolutely NOTHING in common with the virus Brown kept describing? I
found this novel exasperatingly awful. I can't believe I read the whole
thing. Save yourself! Stop now and turn on CBS instead!
As someone in that category myself, I could really relate to her stories
-- her guilt (is this my fault? did I do something wrong? if I don't
want to try something that might help, does that mean I don't want to get
better?), her frustration, her fear that it's "all in her head," and, most
of all, her ultimate decision not to let it rule her life anymore. She
says at one point she felt like she'd become a vagina -- a walking,
talking vagina, the pain had so consumed her world. And that changed
everything. That was unacceptable.
This is a short but incredibly powerful book. Great for chronic pain
warriors (I
prefer that to "patients" or "sufferers") who
crave the validation that comes from hearing someone else articulate what
you feel. And, even better, great for the friends and family of CP
warriors who struggle to understand but so often just cannot. One of the
passages that made me gasp -- I could have written it myself, you see --
was this one:
In the passage just after this one, she describes chronic pain as being
like carrying an unwieldy suitcase around.
It's not that the suitcase is
too heavy to bear -- it's that you can't ever set it down. That's it.
That is EXACTLY it. This is a
marvelous book. Go read it.
His memories of those childhood years plague him, though. Details that he
recalls as an adult take on new meaning and, ultimately, he is driven by
those details to return to China and try to piece together what happened
to
his parents. And it's here where things become truly bizarre. Up to this
point, the novel mostly consists of Banks telling us stories about his
childhood -- not only things he remembered about his parents, but also
about his best friend in Shanghai, a Japanese boy named Akira. After his
father disappeared, Christopher and Akira would spend hours playing
detective together -- making up elaborate theories and inventing clues and
scenarios for rescue. So, is the sudden switch at the end of the book
from England back to Shanghai all in Banks' head? It certainly seemed
unrealistic enough and not only that, but juvenile as well. Banks becomes
obsessed with a clue that only a child would believe held any water so
many years later. He can't see anything but the clue -- he can't
even see the war that is raging in Shanghai, even when he follows that
clue right into the battles themselves. At the time, all I could think
was, "He's supposed to be a famous detective? What the heck is he
thinking?" It wasn't until later that the person who had recommended the
book to me in the first place pointed out that the whole situation so
closely paralleled
the games he played as a youth that it MUST have been some kind of
psychotic break. Not real -- wholly imagined.
This would've been okay with me -- and so would've a straight ending in
which the famous detective really DOES return to try to find his parents.
But instead, the ending is almost too unstable. I couldn't tell if it was
reality or not. Sometimes that's a trick that works, and I won't say I
wasn't thoroughly entertained by it here, because I read the second half
of this novel
in one sitting. But instead of leaving me excited about such an
unpredictable and creative twist, it left me confused and wondering if I'd
missed something.
However, and I want to stress this, I REALLY enjoyed this novel. It is
unusual and extremely well crafted. It would make a terrific selection
for a book club, in particular, because it lends itself so well to
a variety of interpretations. Recommended to anybody who likes a
challenge and who always appreciates fine writing.
[FICTION]
[MYSTERY]
[SCIENCE FICTION]
[FICTION]
[FICTION]
[FICTION]
[CRAP]
[NON-FICTION]
[FICTION]